Krista Mathers
Agent
Testimonials
"
If I could give higher than a 5 star rating I would. Krista went above and beyond for my husband and I, and our first time buying a house. As first time home buyers we were nervous and weren’t really sure how the whole process would go but having Krista help us made this experience very pleasant (and in today’s market was a hard task!) She was super flexible with our schedules and lack of knowledge and really helped give us all the information we needed to not only find our perfect house but make sure that we were investing into a property that would actually be a good one for us and our future and not just any house. After working with her once you can tell she is very dedicated to each and every client she had and their specific needs. We will definitely be reaching out to her for every house buying process we have in the future!
"
- Diana McCaddon (Operations manager)
"
Krista was easy to work with. She helped me from the beginning until the end. It was not an easy sell, but I am glad she was helpful throughout the whole selling process. Her knowledge & pool of contractors was beneficial from day 1.
"
- Melissa J Nichols (Patient Accounts)
"
Krista Mathers definitely gets a 5 star rating in my book. Very thorough , knowledgeable and compassionate about her work. Made selling my house a breeze. I would highly recommend Krista . Thank you for the wonderful opportunity to work with you.
"
- Deborah Wilson
"
Krista is an excellent agent and we would highly recommend her! She put us at ease throughout the process despite a very tough market. She answered all of our questions or was quick to reach out to someone if needed to get us answers. She never pushed us into anything and was honest the entire way and it made us much more comfortable once we found the right home. She’s followed up multiple times since our purchase to check in and make sure everything is going okay and to see our progress. I couldn’t recommend her enough and think that anyone looking for an agent would be lucky to work with her!
"
- Jordan Ellerbrock (First-time Home Buyer)
"
Krista went above and beyond to get us in our first home. She is very professional and knows her stuff! I would recommend her to anyone and everyone!
"
- Myranda Watkins
"
Krista is an excellent agent and we would highly recommend her! She put us at ease throughout the process despite a very tough market. She answered all of our questions or was quick to reach out to someone if needed to get us answers. She never pushed us into anything and was honest the entire way and it made us much more comfortable once we found the right home. She’s followed up multiple times since our purchase to check in and make sure everything is going okay and to see our progress. I couldn’t recommend her enough and think that anyone looking for an agent would be lucky to work with her!
"
- Jordan Ellerbrock (First-time Home Buyer)
"
She was awesome! She super attentive, she helped with every question, concern, and fear. Being a first time homeowner is scary! She helped me feel at ease through the whole process. She kept in the loop through every step of the way! KRISTA ROCKS!!
"
- Rachel Lippert
"
Krista is an exceptional realtor who is experienced, knowledgeable and accessible. Thanks to her expertise and extensive marketing, we were able to sell our home quickly and well above list price. She made the entire home sale process low stress and easy. I would highly recommend her for your home buying and selling needs!
"
- Josh White (District Manager)
"
Krista did an amazing job helping me find any first home. She was patient as I looked over many houses, always quick to respond and chase down the necessary information. She has years of experience and extensive knowledge of the industry. Highly recommended!
"
- Adam Laurer
"
We loved Krista! She made the home buying process so easy! She explained everything so well so my husband and I understood what was happening. If you’re looking to buy a home, Krista is your girl!
"
- Gabrielle Edwards
"
I was very particular about what I wanted. I began to worry that Krista would become agitated with my indecision. She proved to be very patient. We looked at many, many houses before we found one that was just right. I've never seen anyone so positive and upbeat about her job. She's a real go getter. We love our new house. I will recommend her to anybody I know that is looking for a new home
"
- Bruce Hornbeck
"
Krista did a phenomenal job! We ended up having a very difficult home-buying process from the financing standpoint and she was there the whole time to help with our questions and advocate for us! We wouldn’t go with anyone else! Great first time home-buyers agent!
"
- Sierra Sullivan (Registered Nurse)
"
She was awesome! She super attentive, she helped with every question, concern, and fear. Being a first time homeowner is scary! She helped me feel at ease through the whole process. She kept in the loop through every step of the way! KRISTA ROCKS!!
"
- Rachel Lippert
"
Krista did an amazing job helping me find any first home. She was patient as I looked over many houses, always quick to respond and chase down the necessary information. She has years of experience and extensive knowledge of the industry. Highly recommended!
"
- Adam Laurer
"
Krista was a wonderful realtor. With years of real estate experience, she is a wealth of information and knowledge, which was extremely helpful. As first-time home buyers, she was able to answer all of our questions and walk us through the home buying process. It also always felt as if she had our best interest at heart during the searching and buying process. I'm very thankful we had her on our side, and I would highly recommend Krista to anyone looking to buy a home!
"
- Kristin Snyder
"
I would recommend Krista to anybody looking to buy or sell. She has an incredible knack for making miracles happen! With her knowledge and resources she was able to get me in the home I would have never thought possible. Very, very, very good at what she does!!!
"
- Jeffrey stiles
"
I can’t recommend Krista enough. Very easy scheduling to see properties, most that day or next. She was great helping us find a lender for self-employed, which was a challenge. She is very knowledgeable about the whole process which made it easier for us. Thank you Krista
"
- Jeff Stilez
"
I highly recommend Krista. She listened to what we wanted and wasn't frustrated if we looked at something that wasn't what we want. She is extremely knowledgeable about the market and made lots of helpful suggestions. She was even extremely helpful to stage our old house for the market.
"
- Tara Thernes (Infrastructure Systems Engineer)
"
Krista is an excellent agent and we would highly recommend her! She put us at ease throughout the process despite a very tough market. She answered all of our questions or was quick to reach out to someone if needed to get us answers. She never pushed us into anything and was honest the entire way and it made us much more comfortable once we found the right home. She’s followed up multiple times since our purchase to check in and make sure everything is going okay and to see our progress. I couldn’t recommend her enough and think that anyone looking for an agent would be lucky to work with her!
"
- Jordan Ellerbrock (First-time Home Buyer)
"
Krista was so helpful in listing my late father’s property and walking us through the process. We were grateful for her help and expertise through the whole process. Thank you Krista and NextHome.
"
- Allison Potteiger
"
Krista did a phenomenal job! We ended up having a very difficult home-buying process from the financing standpoint and she was there the whole time to help with our questions and advocate for us! We wouldn’t go with anyone else! Great first time home-buyers agent!
"
- Sierra Sullivan (Registered Nurse)
"
I would highly reccommend Krista Hedges for your real estate needs. She was with us every step of the way during this roller coaster ride. She was always quick to respond to our questions or concerns. My family found a place we are happy to call home in which Krista played a huge role in making it happen!
"
- Tammy J Morningstar
"
Krista helped us sell our home fast and above asking price. She is super friendly and very professional. She makes recommendations that help with the sale of the property. My daughter also used Krista to sell her home with the same results. I highly recommend her and if we ever need to sell our home in the future we would definitely use Krista.
"
- Ronni Boehm
"
Krista was amazing! She's extremely knowledgeable and does whatever she can to help find the perfect house. Krista made the home search and buying process so much easier even during a time when buying a house seemed impossible. I definitely plan to use her if/or when we decide to buy again.
"
- Melissa Rubadue
"
We have used Krista Hedges on all our Real Estate purchases. She went way beyond in my last purchase, it was a real testament to persistence in getting the job done!
"
- Kim Wilson
"
Krista is amazing. She cares about her clients wants and needs. Krista is very knowledgeable on many topics, even more than just reality.
"
- Taylor B
"
She was awesome! She super attentive, she helped with every question, concern, and fear. Being a first time homeowner is scary! She helped me feel at ease through the whole process. She kept in the loop through every step of the way! KRISTA ROCKS!!
"
- Rachel Lippert
"
We have used Krista Hedges on all our Real Estate purchases. She went way beyond in my last purchase, it was a real testament to persistence in getting the job done!
"
- Kim Wilson
"
Krista is an excellent agent and we would highly recommend her! She put us at ease throughout the process despite a very tough market. She answered all of our questions or was quick to reach out to someone if needed to get us answers. She never pushed us into anything and was honest the entire way and it made us much more comfortable once we found the right home. She’s followed up multiple times since our purchase to check in and make sure everything is going okay and to see our progress. I couldn’t recommend her enough and think that anyone looking for an agent would be lucky to work with her!
"
- Jordan Ellerbrock (First-time Home Buyer)
"
Krista was a wonderful realtor. With years of real estate experience, she is a wealth of information and knowledge, which was extremely helpful. As first-time home buyers, she was able to answer all of our questions and walk us through the home buying process. It also always felt as if she had our best interest at heart during the searching and buying process. I'm very thankful we had her on our side, and I would highly recommend Krista to anyone looking to buy a home!
"
- Kristin Snyder
"
I can’t recommend Krista enough. Very easy scheduling to see properties, most that day or next. She was great helping us find a lender for self-employed, which was a challenge. She is very knowledgeable about the whole process which made it easier for us. Thank you Krista
"
- Jeff Stilez
"
Krista is an exceptional realtor! She is very professional, considerate, and makes the buying/selling process as easy and painless as possible. She has a tremendous amount of knowledge that she brings to the table, ensuring will get the best price for your home as well as a fair price on your purchase. I highly recommend her for your next real estate purchase/home sale. She’s not just a business professional, but she will also become a friend!
"
- Tara White (Property Manager)
"
I would highly reccommend Krista Hedges for your real estate needs. She was with us every step of the way during this roller coaster ride. She was always quick to respond to our questions or concerns. My family found a place we are happy to call home in which Krista played a huge role in making it happen!
"
- Tammy J Morningstar
"
I was very particular about what I wanted. I began to worry that Krista would become agitated with my indecision. She proved to be very patient. We looked at many, many houses before we found one that was just right. I've never seen anyone so positive and upbeat about her job. She's a real go getter. We love our new house. I will recommend her to anybody I know that is looking for a new home
"
- Bruce Hornbeck
"
Krista was very instrumental in the success of me becoming a homeowner. When the mortgage lender was performing below expectations, she found another lender that had the job done in a matter of weeks. When Krista sees some thing in the paperwork or any of the procedures that didn't meet her standards she immediately corrects the problem or helps find the solution to it. Krista is very personable and cares about her clients and their success in obtaining their dream house. I would highly recommend her to anyone trying to buy a house for the first time or the 100th time!
"
- Clarence smith (Mechanic)
"
Krista went above and beyond to get us in our first home. She is very professional and knows her stuff! I would recommend her to anyone and everyone!
"
- Myranda Watkins
"
If I could give higher than a 5 star rating I would. Krista went above and beyond for my husband and I, and our first time buying a house. As first time home buyers we were nervous and weren’t really sure how the whole process would go but having Krista help us made this experience very pleasant (and in today’s market was a hard task!) She was super flexible with our schedules and lack of knowledge and really helped give us all the information we needed to not only find our perfect house but make sure that we were investing into a property that would actually be a good one for us and our future and not just any house. After working with her once you can tell she is very dedicated to each and every client she had and their specific needs. We will definitely be reaching out to her for every house buying process we have in the future!
"
- Diana McCaddon (Operations manager)
"
Krista did an amazing job working with my family to sell our property. Working with out of state clients can be a challenge and she was on top of everything! Great communication and quick sale!
"
- Shelly Callender
"
Great realtor!
"
- Anonymous
"
Great realtor!
"
- Anonymous
"
Krista was easy to work with. She helped me from the beginning until the end. It was not an easy sell, but I am glad she was helpful throughout the whole selling process. Her knowledge & pool of contractors was beneficial from day 1.
"
- Melissa J Nichols (Patient Accounts)
"
Krista did a phenomenal job! We ended up having a very difficult home-buying process from the financing standpoint and she was there the whole time to help with our questions and advocate for us! We wouldn’t go with anyone else! Great first time home-buyers agent!
"
- Sierra Sullivan (Registered Nurse)
"
Krista was so helpful in listing my late father’s property and walking us through the process. We were grateful for her help and expertise through the whole process. Thank you Krista and NextHome.
"
- Allison Potteiger
"
Krista did a phenomenal job! We ended up having a very difficult home-buying process from the financing standpoint and she was there the whole time to help with our questions and advocate for us! We wouldn’t go with anyone else! Great first time home-buyers agent!
"
- Sierra Sullivan (Registered Nurse)
"
Krista did great with the sale of our vintage property in Ohio. We would give her a 6 star rating if it went above a 5 star rating! Thanks so much to her extra efforts.
"
- Phyllis Bishop (retired Dept of Defense)
"
Krista was very instrumental in the success of me becoming a homeowner. When the mortgage lender was performing below expectations, she found another lender that had the job done in a matter of weeks. When Krista sees some thing in the paperwork or any of the procedures that didn't meet her standards she immediately corrects the problem or helps find the solution to it. Krista is very personable and cares about her clients and their success in obtaining their dream house. I would highly recommend her to anyone trying to buy a house for the first time or the 100th time!
"
- Clarence smith (Mechanic)
"
I highly recommend Krista. She listened to what we wanted and wasn't frustrated if we looked at something that wasn't what we want. She is extremely knowledgeable about the market and made lots of helpful suggestions. She was even extremely helpful to stage our old house for the market.
"
- Tara Thernes (Infrastructure Systems Engineer)
"
Krista is amazing. She cares about her clients wants and needs. Krista is very knowledgeable on many topics, even more than just reality.
"
- Taylor B
"
Krista was amazing! She's extremely knowledgeable and does whatever she can to help find the perfect house. Krista made the home search and buying process so much easier even during a time when buying a house seemed impossible. I definitely plan to use her if/or when we decide to buy again.
"
- Melissa Rubadue
"
I would recommend Krista to anybody looking to buy or sell. She has an incredible knack for making miracles happen! With her knowledge and resources she was able to get me in the home I would have never thought possible. Very, very, very good at what she does!!!
"
- Jeffrey stiles
About Krista Mathers
I know that buying or selling a home is one of the most important things you will ever do, and I want to help make that experience as smooth and successful as possible. My extensive experience and expertise in the real estate market will benefit you whether you are looking to buy or sell a home in the area.Buying a Home? I will help you find the home of your dreams by taking the time to listen and understand your needs and desires. Once I know what you want, I will work tirelessly to find the right home for you, because no one should have to compromise when it comes to such a huge purchase.
Selling your Home? My expertise in the real estate market will help ensure that you get the best price for your property. My finely-tuned marketing program will make sure the right people see your home.
I am always available for personal service by phone or email, so feel free to contact me with questions any time!
Areas We Cover
- Ada
- Akron
- Albany
- Alexandria
- Amanda
- Arlington
- Ashland
- Ashley
- Ashtabula
- Ashville
- Athens
- Aurora
- Bainbridge
- Baltimore
- Barnesville
- Beaver
- Beavercreek
- Belle Center
- Bellefontaine
- Bellevue
- Bellville
- Belmont
- Bexley
- Blacklick
- Bladensburg
- Bloomingburg
- Blue Rock
- Bluffton
- Bowling Green
- Bremen
- Bridgeport
- Brinkhaven
- Broadway
- Brookville
- Brownsville
- Brunswick
- Buckeye Lake
- Bucyrus
- Cable
- Caldwell
- Caledonia
- Cambridge
- Canal Winchester
- Cardington
- Carroll
- Centerburg
- Chandlersville
- Chesapeake
- Chesterville
- Chillicothe
- Cincinnati
- Circleville
- Clarksville
- Cleveland
- Columbus
- Commercial Point
- Conesville
- Conneaut
- Coolville
- Corning
- Coshocton
- Creola
- Crestline
- Crooksville
- Croton
- Crown City
- Dalton
- Danville
- Dayton
- Degraff
- Delaware
- Dexter
- Dover
- Dresden
- Dublin
- Duncan Falls
- Dundee
- Dunkirk
- East Fultonham
- Edison
- Englewood
- Enon
- Etna
- Euclid
- Fairborn
- Findlay
- Frankfort
- Franklin
- Frazeysburg
- Fredericktown
- Fresno
- Gahanna
- Galena
- Galion
- Gallipolis
- Galloway
- Gambier
- Geneva
- Glenford
- Glenmont
- Glouster
- Grandview Heights
- Granville
- Gratiot
- Greenfield
- Greenville
- Greenwich
- Grove City
- Groveport
- Hanover
- Harrisburg
- Haydenville
- Heath
- Hebron
- Hide A Way Hills
- Hilliard
- Hillsboro
- Hopewell
- Howard
- Huber Heights
- Huntsville
- Ironton
- Irwin
- Jackson
- Jacksontown
- Jamestown
- Jeffersonville
- Johnstown
- Junction City
- Kenton
- Kingston
- Kirkersville
- La Rue
- Lakeview
- Lancaster
- Langsville
- Laurelville
- Leesburg
- Lewis Center
- Lexington
- Lithopolis
- Little Hocking
- Lockbourne
- Logan
- London
- Long Bottom
- Lorain
- Lore City
- Lower Salem
- Lucas
- Lucasville
- Malta
- Mansfield
- Maple Heights
- Marble Cliff
- Marengo
- Marietta
- Marion
- Marshallville
- Marysville
- Mason
- McArthur
- McDermott
- McGuffey
- Mcconnelsville
- Mechanicsburg
- Medina
- Miamisburg
- Middleport
- Milan
- Milford Center
- Millersport
- Millfield
- Minster
- Montpelier
- Morral
- Mount Gilead
- Mount Perry
- Mount Sterling
- Mount Vernon
- Nashport
- Nelsonville
- Nevada
- New Albany
- New Bloomington
- New Carlisle
- New Concord
- New Holland
- New Lexington
- New Marshfield
- New Matamoras
- New Philadelphia
- New Plymouth
- New Straitsville
- Newark
- Newcomerstown
- North Bend
- North Lewisburg
- Northfield
- Norwalk
- Norwich
- Oak Hill
- Obetz
- Ontario
- Orient
- Ostrander
- Pataskala
- Patriot
- Perrysburg
- Philo
- Pickerington
- Piketon
- Plain City
- Pleasantville
- Plymouth
- Portsmouth
- Powell
- Proctorville
- Prospect
- Quaker City
- Quincy
- Radnor
- Ray
- Raymond
- Reedsville
- Reynoldsburg
- Richwood
- Rockbridge
- Roseville
- Rushsylvania
- Rushville
- Russells Point
- Sabina
- Saint Louisville
- Saint Paris
- Sardis
- Senecaville
- Shade
- Shelby
- Shiloh
- Sidney
- Somerset
- South Bloomfield
- South Bloomingville
- South Charleston
- South Salem
- South Solon
- South Vienna
- Springfield
- St. Clairsville
- St. Marys
- Stockport
- Stout
- Stoutsville
- Stow
- Strasburg
- Sugar Grove
- Sunbury
- The Plains
- Thompson
- Thornville
- Thurman
- Thurston
- Tipp City
- Trenton
- Trimble
- Trinway
- Troy
- Union
- Uniontown
- Upper Arlington
- Upper Sandusky
- Urbana
- Urbancrest
- Utica
- Vermilion
- Vinton
- Waldo
- Walhonding
- Warsaw
- Washington Court House
- Waverly
- Wellston
- West Jefferson
- West Liberty
- West Mansfield
- West Rushville
- West Salem
- Westerville
- Westfield Center
- Westlake
- Wheelersburg
- Whitehall
- Wilkesville
- Willard
- Williamsport
- Wilmington
- Woodstock
- Worthington
- Xenia
- Yellow Springs
- Youngstown
- Zanesfield
- Zanesville
MLS® Disclaimer
Columbus REALTOR® and Central Ohio Regional Multiple Listing Service, Inc .All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumer's personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective
properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of the Multiple Listing Service. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than NextHome Experience may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. Copyright ©2026 All rights reserved.
Last Updated: September 21, 2026 8:01 PM UTC
Show More...
Apply today, your next place is waiting!
Request an application for this rental listing through our trusted partner, Rental Beast, and enjoy the benefits:
One-time Application Fee
Use your application with participating Rental Beast properties for 30 days with no additional cost.
Seamless Application Process
Request an application and begin yours online in seconds.
Soft Credit Check Only
A soft credit inquiry is used and does not impact your credit score.
Fast-tracked Reviews
Quick processing gets you closer to moving day, faster.
Disclaimer: By providing my phone number above and checking this box, I expressly consent to NextHome Experience, directly or by a third party vendor, InsideRE, LLC, acting on NextHome Experience's behalf, contacting me at this number by calling me or sending me text messages, including marketing and promotional messages, using an automatic telephone dialing system, related to our products and services for real estate transactions, even if my name appears on the "Do Not Call" list. Providing my consent is not required to obtain our products or services. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency varies. Text HELP for help or STOP to opt out.